Usage-based pricing (per-seat or per-email) is a legacy SaaS billing model where costs increase linearly with scale, punishing high-volume senders. In contrast, the “Unlimited” model separates software fees from infrastructure costs (BYO-SMTP), allowing businesses to send 100,000+ emails for a flat rate. As cold email shifts toward decentralized infrastructure in 2026, the per-seat model is becoming mathematically obsolete for growth teams.
The “Success Tax” in Cold Email
Imagine a car rental company that charges you not just for the car, but for every mile you drive and every passenger you carry. That is the state of the cold email industry today.
Tools like Lemlist, Instantly (legacy plans), and Outreach charge “Per Seat” (user) or “Per Email.”
- The Trap: If your campaign works, you want to scale.
- The Punishment: To scale, you must add more seats (inboxes). Your bill doubles.
This creates a Success Tax. The better you perform, the more margin you lose. This article breaks down the hard mathematics of why smart teams are migrating to Unlimited/BYO-SMTP platforms like Email 360 Pro.
1. The Economics of Scale: A Cost Comparison
Let’s look at the math for a standard agency or growth team sending 100,000 emails/month.
To send 100k emails safely (50/day limit), you need ~100 inboxes.
The “Per-Seat” Competitor (e.g., $29/seat)
Most popular tools charge roughly $29 to $50 per connected email account (seat).
- Software Cost: 100 inboxes x $29 = $2,900 / month.
- Infrastructure: Included (usually), but often shared IP reputation.
- Total Annual Cost: $34,800.
The “Unlimited” Model (Email 360 Pro)
You pay a flat fee for the software interface, and you bring your own infrastructure (Google Workspace, SMTP, etc.).
- Software Cost: Flat fee (e.g., $97 / month).
- Infrastructure: * Option A (Workspace): You pay Google directly ($6/user).
- Option B (SMTP): You pay Amazon SES ($0.10 per 1,000 emails).
- Total Monthly (with SMTP): $97 (Software) + $10 (SES) = $107 / month.
- Total Annual Cost: $1,284.
The Result: The Per-Seat model is 2,600% more expensive for the exact same volume.
2. The “Hidden” Costs of Per-Seat SaaS
The sticker price isn’t the only problem. Usage-based tools hide costs in their “Fair Use” policies.
The Warm-Up Cap
Many per-seat tools cap your “Warm-Up” volume. They might allow 50 emails/day for sending, but charge extra if you want to warm up faster.
- Unlimited Model: Warm-up is typically uncapped because the software provider isn’t paying for the server load—you are (via your SMTP).
The Member Seat vs. Sending Seat
Some tools charge you for “Team Members” (people logging in) separate from “Sending Accounts.”
- If you have 5 SDRs and 20 inboxes, you pay for 25 seats.
- In the Unlimited model, you typically pay for the platform, regardless of how many team members login.
3. Why “BYO-SMTP” is the Future of Deliverability
Beyond cost, the biggest reason usage-based tools are dying is Control.
When you pay $29/seat for an “all-in-one” tool, you are sending through their shared IPs (or a simplified relay). If another user on their platform spams, your deliverability suffers.
The BYO-SMTP Shift:
- Ownership: You connect your own Amazon SES, SendGrid, or private Postfix server.
- Isolation: Your reputation is 100% yours. No “noisy neighbors.”
- Portability: If you hate the software interface, you can unplug your SMTP and plug it into a different tool without losing your sender history.
4. The Agency Margin Crisis
Lead Generation Agencies are hit hardest by per-seat pricing.
- Scenario: You charge a client $2,000/month for leads.
- Per-Seat Cost: To get results, you need 20 inboxes. Cost: $600/month.
- Margin: Your software eats 30% of your revenue.
With Unlimited pricing, your software cost is fixed. If you sign 10 new clients, your software bill stays $97. Your margin on the 10th client is nearly 100%.
5. When Does Per-Seat Still Make Sense?
We will be honest: “Unlimited” isn’t for everyone.
- The Solopreneur: If you only send 20 emails a day and have 1 inbox, paying $29/month is easier than setting up SMTP.
- The Non-Technical: Setting up DKIM/SPF for SMTP takes 15 minutes. If you refuse to learn that, pay the premium for per-seat convenience.
But for anyone scaling past 5,000 emails/month, per-seat is a tax on growth.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)
Q1: What exactly is “BYO-SMTP”? A: It stands for “Bring Your Own Simple Mail Transfer Protocol.” It means the software (like Email 360 Pro) acts as the dashboard/interface, but the actual emails are sent through a third-party engine you control (like Gmail API, Outlook, Amazon SES, or Mailgun).
Q2: Is setting up SMTP difficult? A: It has a learning curve of about 30 minutes. You need to copy-paste some text records (DNS) into your domain host. Once set up, it requires zero maintenance. We provide step-by-step guides for all major providers.
Q3: Can I switch from Per-Seat to Unlimited without losing data? A: Yes. Most Unlimited platforms (including ours) allow you to import leads and “Do Not Contact” lists via CSV. However, you will need to reconnect your email accounts.
Q4: Does “Unlimited” mean I can spam? A: Absolutely not. “Unlimited” refers to the pricing cap, not the laws of physics. If you send 10,000 emails from one inbox in a day, you will be banned by Google, regardless of what software you use.
Q5: Why do competitors charge per seat if it’s so expensive? A: Because it is incredibly profitable for them. It is the legacy model inherited from Salesforce and HubSpot. They rely on customers not doing the math or being afraid of technical setup.
Q6: Are there hidden costs with Unlimited plans? A: The only “external” cost is your email provider. If you use Amazon SES, it costs ~$1 per 10,000 emails. If you use Google Workspace, you pay Google’s standard fee. But you pay these directly to the provider, with no markup from us.
Q7: Can I manage multiple clients on one Unlimited plan? A: Yes. This is a key feature for agencies. You can create “Workspaces” or “Sub-accounts” for different clients under one master subscription, keeping their data separate while paying one flat fee.
Q8: Does Per-Seat offer better support? A: Generally, no. Support quality depends on the company culture, not the billing model. In fact, BYO-SMTP platforms often have more technical support teams because they assist with DNS and server configurations.
Q9: What happens if I scale down? A: With Unlimited, you pay the same flat rate. With Per-Seat, your bill drops. However, the break-even point is usually so low (e.g., 3-4 inboxes) that Unlimited remains cheaper even at low volumes.
Q10: Is Amazon SES quality good enough for cold email? A: Yes, if configured correctly. While Google Workspace IPs have a higher default reputation, Amazon SES is used by companies like Netflix and Uber. If your content is good and list is clean, SES delivers perfectly well.
Q11: Can I mix Workspace and SMTP accounts on an Unlimited plan? A: Yes. A common strategy is to use high-quality Workspace accounts for “Tier A” prospects (CEOs) and cheaper SMTP accounts for “Tier B” volume. Unlimited platforms let you route these in the same campaign.
Q12: Why don’t all tools offer Unlimited? A: Because it requires a different software architecture. Tools built for per-seat billing often have “heavy” infrastructure costs they pass on to you. Unlimited tools are built to be lightweight “command centers.”
Q13: Do Unlimited plans include email verification? A: Some do, some don’t. Email 360 Pro includes a built-in verifier. Often, per-seat tools charge extra credits for verification on top of the seat price.
Q14: Is Per-Seat pricing ever better for cash flow? A: Only in the very beginning (Months 1-2) if you have $0 budget. But as soon as you add your second or third inbox, the cost rapidly overtakes the flat-fee model.
Q15: What is the “Rotation” feature mentioned in Unlimited plans? A: Inbox Rotation (automating sending across multiple accounts) is standard in Unlimited plans because they encourage you to add more inboxes. Per-seat tools often gate this feature behind “Enterprise” tiers because they want you to buy more seats manually.
Stop Paying the Success Tax
You shouldn’t be punished for growing. Switch to the infrastructure that supports scale.
[Link: Compare Your Savings with the Calculator]